• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
Tasty Treats and Eats
menu icon
go to homepage
  • About Me
  • Recipes
    • Brownies
    • Cake
    • Candy
    • Cheesecake
    • Cookies
    • Cupcakes
    • Pies and Tarts
  • Contact
  • Subscribe
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
  • search icon
    Homepage link
    • About Me
    • Recipes
      • Brownies
      • Cake
      • Candy
      • Cheesecake
      • Cookies
      • Cupcakes
      • Pies and Tarts
    • Contact
    • Subscribe
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
  • ×

    Home » Pies and Tarts » Easy Custard Pie Recipe

    Easy Custard Pie Recipe

    November 16, 2022 by Liz @ Tasty Treats & Eats 2 Comments

    502 shares
    Jump to Recipe Print Recipe
    Easy Custard Pie

    This Custard Pie Recipe is so simple to make. An egg custard pie that is old fashioned and absolutely delicious! A must try!

    slice of custard pie on a plate

    This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Click here to read my policy about affiliate links.

    This Custard Pie is perfect for the holidays, or any time you're looking for a sweet treat!

    Buttery pie crust and a rich, creamy filling make for the perfect dessert! If you've never tried egg custard pie, it's easy to make and delicious!

    overhead of two slices of custard pie on plates with forks

    What is Custard Pie?

    A traditional custard pie is usually a mixture of eggs, milk, sugar, salt, and vanilla. Often with a sprinkling of freshly grated nutmeg on top. A creamy, simple but delicious pie everyone will love.

    Why You Will Love this Old Fashioned Custard Pie

    • Old Fashioned: This is a recipe that has gone through many generations! Classic and delicious!
    • Cheap: With grocery store costs on the rise, this is a delicious, simple, budget-friendly dessert!
    • Total Comfort Food: When you need something comforting, this is the ultimate recipe!

    Egg Custard Pie Ingredients

    To make egg custard pie you'll need:

    • Homemade pie crust or store-bought
    • Eggs
    • Heavy cream
    • Whole milk
    • White sugar
    • Vanilla extract
    • Sea salt
    • Ground nutmeg
    custard pie ingredients

    How To Make This Easy Custard Pie Recipe

    1. Preheat the oven and spray an 8-inch pie pan with nonstick cooking spray.
    2. Make your pie crust and line the prepared pan with it, crimping the edges as you desire.
    3. Combine all ingredients except the nutmeg, in a large bowl and whisk well. 
    4. Pour into the unbaked pie crust and sprinkle the top with the desired amount of nutmeg.
    5. Cook for 40 minutes or until a toothpick inserted in the middle comes out clean.
    6. Let cool on the counter for 1 hour then place in the fridge and cool for 2 hours.
    custard filling in a mixing bowl
    pie crust pressed into a pie plate
    custard filling in the pie crust
    raw custard pie with spices on top
    fully baked custard pie

    How to Store Custard Pie Recipe:

    Storing: Once the custard pie has cooled properly, cover tightly in plastic wrap and store in the refrigerator for up to 4 days. Check out this post on how to store pies.

    Freezing: Freezing a custard pie is possible, but not for long as the ingredients may separate and that lovely texture you love in a custard pie will not last.

    If you are to freeze your custard pie, allow it to cool, wrap it in plastic wrap and freeze. Best if frozen for as little time as possible, no longer than a month.

    Defrost a frozen custard pie in the refrigerator.

    a whole custard pie with a slice cut out

    Substitutions for this Custard Pie Recipe:

    Homemade pie crust or Store-bought pie crust: Whichever pie shell option you choose will be great, a pie crust from the store will save precious time.

    Eggs: We don't recommend substituting eggs, but you can read this article on Egg Substitutions for Baking if you need to substitute. Try it at your own risk!

    Heavy Cream: You can substitute heavy cream with half and half. Heavy cream will offer a creamy texture and richness that half and half may not provide.

    Milk: You can substitute milk with half and half, low fat milk or non dairy milk.

    Sugar: We don't recommend substituting white sugar unless you have to, but White sugar can be used interchangeably with brown sugar. You can add 1 teaspoon of molasses to white sugar to make brown sugar. Check out this post on Sugar Substitutes for Baking for other ideas.

    Vanilla Extract: Helps to add flavor, we don't recommend substituting.

    Sea Salt: Helps to add flavor, we don't recommend substituting.

    Ground Nutmeg: In a pinch, if you do not have nutmeg, cinnamon is a good replacement. Nutmeg is delicious so I would splurge for it.

     Custard Pie Recipe Tips

    • Fresh Nutmeg: Having freshly grated nutmeg is a treat, you'll love it.
    • Pour Slowly: To avoid air bubbles and an eggy mess, pour your custard egg mixture slowly into your pie crust.
    • Let the pie cool!: I know you want to eat this lovely pie right away, it's essential to allow this custard pie to chill and set completely before slicing.
    slice of custard pie on a plate with a fork

    Egg Custard Pie Recipe FAQs

    Why Did My Custard Pie Sink in the Middle?

    Custard pie prefers to cool off slowly. When your pie is finished baking and there's still a jiggle in the center of your pie, turn the oven off and prop the door open. Allow the pie and the oven to cool together. Cooling a custard pie this way prevents sinking and wrinkling. After this cooling process, it's okay to chill your pie in the refrigerator to set up the rest of the way.

    Should You Refrigerate Custard Pie?

    Yes, because custard pie is made with eggs and dairy it should not be left out of the refrigerator for longer than two hours. Custard pies will stay good for up to 2 days in the refrigerator.

    What is Custard Pie Filling?

    A traditional custard pie is usually a mixture of eggs, milk, sugar, salt, and vanilla. Often with a sprinkling of nutmeg on top. Unlike a cream pie, a custard filling is baked inside of an uncooked pie crust or par-baked crust.

    Why is My Egg Custard Pie Runny?

    If the proper storage is used, your custard pie shouldn’t get runny. The runny issue often hits when people have stored or chilled the pie. Plastic wrap seems to collect moisture with the pie, so try not to use it when storing the pie. It also will get watery if the pie is placed in the fridge while still too hot. This is why it’s important to let the pie chill for a while before placing it in the fridge. 

    overhead over custard pie with two slices taken out and a slice on a plate with a fork

    More Dessert Recipes You’re Sure To Love:

    • Homemade Peach Pie Filling
    • Mini Blueberry Lemon Tarts
    • Mini Cherry Pies
    • Vegan Key Lime Pie
    • Easy No Bake Peanut Butter Pie
    slice of custard pie on a plate with a fork

    Egg Custard Pie Recipe

    If you love a good old fashioned recipe, you’re going to be head over heels for this Custard Pie. A classic pie crust on the bottom and a creamy, silky sweet custard center to finish it off. This dessert takes a few ingredients and is super easy to toss together. 
    5 from 2 votes
    Print Pin Rate
    Course: Dessert
    Cuisine: American
    Keyword: easy custard pie, egg custard pie, old-fashioned custard pie
    Prep Time: 5 minutes
    Cook Time: 40 minutes
    Total Time: 45 minutes
    Servings: 8 slices (1 pie)
    Calories: 331kcal

    Ingredients

    • 1 homemade pie crust or store bought
    • 4 eggs
    • 1 cup heavy cream
    • 1 ⅓ cups whole milk
    • ¾ cup white sugar
    • 1 tablespoon vanilla extract
    • ⅛ teaspoon sea salt
    • ground nutmeg

    Instructions

    • Preheat the oven to 350 degrees and spray an 8-inch pie pan with nonstick cooking spray or grease with butter. 
    • Make your pie crust and line the prepared pan with it, crimping the edges as you desire.
    • Combine all ingredients except the nutmeg, in a large bowl and whisk well. 
    • Pour into the prepared crust and sprinkle the top with the desired amount of nutmeg.
    • Cook for 40 minutes or until a toothpick inserted in the middle comes out clean.
    • Let cool on the counter for 1 hour then place in the fridge and cool for 2 hours or chilled through.

    Notes

  • Storage - Store in a sealed container or covered in the pie pan, in the fridge, for up to 4 days. Store in an airtight container, in the freezer, for up to 2 months. 
  • Reheating -  Reheat using the microwave after letting the pie recipe thaw a bit on its own.
  • Do not use a store-bought crust - Store-bought crusts have a major shrinking issue. If you really need to use a store-bought crust, be sure to use the kind you roll out and shape on your own. This way, you can ensure it’s got plenty of extra room on all edges before crimping. This way, if it shrinks, it won’t mess up the pie. 
  • Nutrition

    Serving: 1slice | Calories: 331kcal | Carbohydrates: 32g | Protein: 6g | Fat: 20g | Saturated Fat: 10g | Polyunsaturated Fat: 2g | Monounsaturated Fat: 6g | Trans Fat: 1g | Cholesterol: 120mg | Sodium: 433mg | Potassium: 143mg | Fiber: 1g | Sugar: 22g | Vitamin A: 622IU | Vitamin C: 1mg | Calcium: 87mg | Iron: 1mg
    « Cranberry and Orange Scones
    Valentine’s Easy Toffee Recipe »

    Reader Interactions

    Comments

    1. Juanita

      August 02, 2022 at 1:37 pm

      5 stars
      I luv egg custard pie my mom and grandma makes the best and so do I and I grew up using only Watkins flavors it makes everything u bake POPS Delicious off to kitchen to make one Happy Cooking.

      Reply
    2. Virginia Roberts

      December 02, 2022 at 1:23 pm

      5 stars
      fantastic web site

      Reply

    Leave a Reply Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Recipe Rating




    Primary Sidebar

    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest

    Hi, I'm Liz! On Tasty Treats & Eats you'll find simple, delicious desserts that you can enjoy in no time!

    More about me →

    Popular

    • Best Fudgy Brownie Recipe
    • Easy Edible Sugar Cookie Dough Recipe
    • Moist Banana Cake Recipe
    • Best Spritz Cookie Recipe

    Seasonal

    • Valentine’s Easy Toffee Recipe
    • Homemade Red Velvet Cupcakes
    • Valentine Brownies Heart Shaped
    • Valentine’s Frosted Sugar Cookie Bars

    Footer

    About

    • Privacy Policy
    • About
    • Contact
    • Web Stories

    Newsletter

    • Sign Up! for emails and updates

    As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

    Copyright © 2022 Tasty Treats and Eats

    ↑ back to top